Inframark response to the District about the Hatch lift station demand, with work order 3156764 (September 9, 2024)
Unofficial searchable copy. For the official record, use the district’s own copy.
2024document2024-09-09 2024-09-092024-09-09-doc-inframark-response-hatch-demand-with-wo-31567642024-09-09Page 1
Page | 1 www.inframark.com 2002 West Grand Parkway North Suite 100 Katy, TX 77449 267-850-4823 September 9, 2024 Cole Konopka Coats Rose Terrace 2, 2700 Via Fortuna, Suite 350 Austin, Texas 78746 Barry Rabon Coats Rose 9 Greenway Plaza, Suite 100 Houston, Texas 77046 RE: Demand for payment, Hatch Lift Station Mr. Konopka and Mr. Rabon, Thank you for your letter dated July 18, 2024 containing a demand for payment regarding alleged damages to the (the “District”) Hatch lift station (the “Hatch LS”) and subsequent letter dated August 7, 2024 providing additional information on the alleged damage to the Hatch LS. In these two letters, the District alleges that Inframark, LLC (“Inframark”) breached the Amended and Restated Operation and Maintenance Agreement (the “Agreement”) with the District and/or negligent performed the services. To summarize the allegations of the District’s August 7, 2024 letter, the District made the following allegations regarding Inframark’s responsibility for the Hatch LS damages: - Inframark did not perform its obligation to check the Hatch LS on a daily basis or monitor alarms from the Hatch LS and respond accordingly1. - Inframark was negligent when it switched high water level alarms to be email and text notifications rather than phone call notifications in response to an issue with the sump pump that was found on February 28, 2023; further, Inframark was negligent in not taking the action to install a temporary sump pump at the Hatch LS. - Inframark failed to take proper responsive action when water was discovered in the Hatch LS on March 7, 2023. - Inframark did not properly respond to a possible sewer spill that was report on March 9, 2023. 1 It should be noted that Inframark is not required to check the Hatch LS on a daily basis but is only required to perform daily alarm checks.
Page 2
Page | 2 www.inframark.com 2002 West Grand Parkway North Suite 100 Katy, TX 77449 267-850-4823 The District alleges that because Inframark’s breached the Agreement or was negligent, a sump pump leak occurred and water levels rose over a period of days; said water damaged the Hatch LS. As a result of these alleged breaches or negligence, the District alleges the Hatch LS failed and was damaged resulting in out-of-pocket expenses to the District of $140,430.90; the District has requested that Inframark reimburse it for said expenses. Inframark has reviewed the allegations in this letter and disagrees that it failed to meet its contractual obligations or otherwise performed any services in a negligent manner. Throughout the Agreement, Inframark performed required checks and monitoring for the Hatch LS. While Inframark did not physically visit the Hatch LS on a daily basis, Inframark performed daily checks of the Hatch LS through BirdNest or GuardDog, which are programs that allow remote monitoring and checking on flows, alarms, and other issues . Inframark performed physical inspections of the Hatch LS on February 23, 2023, February 28, 2023, March 2, 2023, March 6, 2023, and March 9, 2023 and routinely performed remote checks, at least once daily, using the BirdNest or GuardDog remote monitoring programs to check flows, alarms, and other issues. At all times during this period, Inframark performed its required checks of the Hatch LS. On February 28, 2023, Inframark discovered that the Hatch LS’s sump pump and a check valve were not functioning properly. Upon discovery of these issues at the Hatch LS, Inframark promptly obtained a quote from Alterman Electric (“Alterman) for the repairs and engaged Alterman to complete the repairs. The check valve generally prevents backflows to occur so due to the issues with the check valve, Inframark received constant phone alarms about backflows and/or water levels at the Hatch LS; these were false alarms and only being received because the check valve was down. Despite the repeated alarms, Inframark continued to check and monitor the Hatch LS and each alarm received to ensure an issue requiring attention was not the cause. However, Inframark switched the alarm notifications phone alarms to text and email alarms to avoid the phone calls for false alarms. A reasonable operator performing in accordance with industry standards would switch from phone alarms to text and email alarms to avoid the constant false alarms but still be able to properly monitor the Hatch LS. Inframark also performed daily checks of the Hatch LS, whether physically or remotely, to ensure it was functioning properly. The District has alleged that the sump pump failure resulted in water gradually accumulating in the Hatch LS and that caused the damages to the Hatch LS. However, that is not the case. On March 7, 20232, Inframark received a notification for high water levels at the Hatch LS. Inframark promptly responded to this notification to investigate the alarm. Upon Inframark’s inspection of this high-water level alarm, it was determined that the alarm was received due to the sump pump needing repairs and not because there were actually high-water levels; Inframark had already received a quote and engaged Alterman to perform the repairs. In essence, this was a false alarm where no action was required and there were not high-water levels in the Hatch LS. This also indicates that Inframark was 2 Our Work Orders indicate that this occurred on March 6, 2023, not March 7, 2023.
Page 3
Page | 3 www.inframark.com 2002 West Grand Parkway North Suite 100 Katy, TX 77449 267-850-4823 monitoring the email and text alarms and responding promptly and accordingly. Further, Inframark received a call from a resident on March 9, 2023 about a possible sewer spill near the Hatch LS. Inframark investigated the call from the resident upon receipt and checked the Hatch LS at that time. As noted in Work Order 3156764, which is attached for reference, the Inframark technician investigated the matter, inspected the Hatch LS, and noted “arrived and lift station is normal”; this occurred between 11:38 AM and 12:03 PM on March 9, 2023. Later on March 9, 2023, there was a ¾ inch air bleed line break at the Hatch LS that enabled 800 gallons per minute to flood the Hatch LS. Such an immediate flood of water could not have been remedied or prevented by Inframark inspections, a phone notice, or any temporary sump pump. There was no reasonable actions or inspection measures Inframark could have performed to prevent this issue3; even a temporary sump pump would have had no impact as a sump pump is designed to remove nominal amounts of water that accumulates due to heavy rain and condensation, not to address a release 800 gallons of water per minute. For these reasons, Inframark met its contractual obligations or performed its services a proper manner that met or exceeded industry standards and the actions of a reasonable operator in similar circumstances. Any alleged damage to the Hatch LS was due to events beyond Inframark’s reasonable control and Inframark’s performance did not cause or contribute to any such damages. Therefore, it is our position that Inframark is not responsible for the alleged $140,430.90 in out-of-pocket expenses incurred by the District related to the Hatch LS. Thank you for time and consideration of our position on this matter. I am available to discuss further at your convenience at 267-850-4823. Inframark is also willing to engage in further good faith discussion regarding this matter. Very truly yours, /s/ Michael Alpago Michael Alpago In-House Legal Counsel Inframark, LLC Cc: Todd Burrer 3 It should be noted that on July 21, 2021, the District’s engineer recommended that the District should raise the electrical system in the Hatch LS so it wouldn’t be susceptible to flooding; however, the District did not accept or follow that recommendation.
Page 4
INFRAMARK Work Order District: WTC1 WO#: 3156764 Dept: 5525 WO Type: LS Resp: OPS Issued: 3/9/2023 Asset ID/Description: WTC1-LS1/Williamson - Travis County MUD # 1 - Lift Station # 1 (Dry Well) Activity Code/Description: LSINVPRB/Investigate a Problem at a Lift Station Address/Location: 3211 Hatch Ln Sched: Additional Address/Location or Task Details: Customer Service Report - Sewer Flowing into parking lot from station. Req By: Rose/Metco Self Storage 512-219-3255 Assigned To: Accounts Receivable GL Code: 40500 Utility Staking #: UCC Start: UCC End: OLD Meter ID: Read: MIU: Special Class: NEW Meter ID: Read: MIU: Gallons Flushed: Date Complete: 3/9/2023 Attachments: 5 Backcharge To: L-B-S: Material / Inventory ID Vendor / Description Vndr Bill PO# / P-Card Qty Price MS72 MISC. Photos 5.00 $0.00 Labor / Equipment ID Job Class Date Units OT? Price 605599 3/9/2023 0.75 N $0.00 TX120184 - Maintenance Truck MTRK 3/9/2023 0.75 N $0.00 Milestone: Closed Invoice#: 1145607 Date Invoiced: 3/31/2023 Total Price: $0.00 Mgr Rev Req: No Bid Price: $0.00 Manager Name: Billing Notification: No Field Comments: 03-09-23. JP Investigated possible sewer spill at lift station. Arrived and lift station is normal. Looked around and noticed standing water across street. Made customer contact and explained that that area belongs to city of cedar park and not to Inframark. Affected address is 3250 Hatch rd. Completion Status: Page 1 of 1