Letter from Coats Rose to Inframark about the Hatch lift station demand (August 7, 2024)
Unofficial searchable copy. For the official record, use the district’s own copy.
2024document2024-08-07 2024-08-072024-08-07-doc-coats-rose-letter-to-inframark-hatch-demand2024-08-07Page 1
COATS ROSE A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION BARRY RABON DIRECTOR BRABON@COATSROSE.COM DIRECT: (713) 653-5757 FAX: (713) 890-3947 9 GREENWAY PLAZA, STE 1000, HOUSTON, TEXAS 77046 PHONE: (713) 651-0111 FAX: (713) 651-0220 coatsrose.com HOUSTON | AUSTIN | DALLAS | CINCINNATI 018330.000008/4869-8083-1957.v1 August 7, 2024 Via E-Mail michael.alpago@inframark.com and Certified Mail RRR Inframark, LLC 2002 West Grand Parkway North Suite 110 Katy, Texas 77449 Attn: Michael Alpago Re: Demand for payment, Hatch Lift Station Dear Mr. Alpago: In response to your email of July 24, 2024, please see the following: - How Inframark allegedly breached its contractual obligations 1. Paragraph 2.6 lists a number of obligations for the Operator. It is reasonable to expect that any Operator when receiving alarms that the dry well of a lift station has high water levels would acknowledge the alarms, visit the site, pump down the water, inspect what caused the water build up, install protective measures to keep water from building up to damage equipment, and monitor the situation adequately until resolved. 2. Schedule 1 states that a “Tech” will do “Daily Alarm Checks (Lift Stations)” as part of their base fee. If daily checks were completed during the window of being alerted to high water levels and adequate care was implemented at each visit, then it is reasonable to assume that water would not have built up to a point of damaging the facility. The virtual log book, physical log book, and work order history indicate gaps between lift station visits or at minimum gaps between logs of visiting the site. 3. Schedule 1 states that a “Tech” will “Record and Log Data” as part of their base fee; daily recordation and logs are not available throughout the window.
Page 2
Michael Alpago Page 2 of 3 August 7, 2024 - How Inframark allegedly negligently performed its contractual obligations 1. Based on records provided by Operator, 1. a notification of high-level alarm was received on 2/28/2023 and it was recorded that the sump pump was not keeping up and one of the pumps was leaking. The operator logged that they changed the alarm to be email and text only so it would quit calling but so that they could still keep track; 2. it was logged that they opened the inspection hatch on 3/7/2023 to the dry well and saw water in the bottom of the dry well. Carlos Perez was called about the water, and he advised that contractors were working on the problem. 3. it was logged on 3/9/2023 that they were called to the site by customer to investigate a possible sewer spill. The operator looked around and saw standing water across the street but notified the customer that the area belongs to the City of Cedar Park not Inframark. That same day, the Operator was called to the site for a possible manhole stoppage and found a leak. The Operator noticed that the wet well and dry well were full and initiated immediate emergency hauling. It was negligent to not install a temporary sump pump when it was noticed that the sump pump was not keeping up and the pumps were leaking; that the alarm method was modified; that nothing was logged between 2/28 and 3/7; that upon noticing water in the dry well again on 3/7 again a temporary sump pump was not installed; that upon being notified of a spill, adequate inspection measures were not conducted and it took another call to identify the problem. - What alleged actions or inactions led to the failure of the Hatch Lift Station 1. modifying the alarm method 2. not adequately addressing alarms, not installing temporary sump pumping, not repairing pump leak, not setting up for emergency hauling, not checking on lift station daily per the contract requirements. - How Inframark’s alleged actions or inactions led to the failure of the Hatch Lift Station 1. Because the alarms were modified, the lift station was not checked daily at minimum per contract, the sump pumps were not assisted with additional pumping capacity, the pump leak was allowed to continue, the water level continued to rise over a period of days and submerged the pumps, motors, and
Page 3
Michael Alpago Page 3 of 3 August 7, 2024 electrical equipment rendering the facility damaged and incapable of normal operations - What damage did the Hatch Lift Station incur and what were the costs for such damages 1. The pumping & electrical equipment within the dry well required repair and replacement, the electrical equipment controlling the lift station were rendered inoperable and required replacement, and the dry well & wet well required emergency hauling. - What engineering and emergency response costs were incurred by WTCMUD1 1. WTCMUD1 paid their previous engineer, Grey Engineering, for their time to be involved in the emergency situation; paid Inframark for emergency services; paid sludge hauler for emergency services; paid Alterman for emergency electrical services; paid Liberty Civil for emergency services. WTCMUD1 is willing to meet with Inframark prior to mediation. You can coordinate a meeting with Cole Konopka, Of Counsel with Coats Rose at 713-653-7379 or via email at ckonopka@coatsrose.com Thanks, you and please contact me if you need additional information. Sincerely, Barry S. Rabon BSR/mf